QUANTUS LEARN
Asset Allocation Backtests: How to Read VAA, GEM and LAA Rules
How dynamic asset allocation uses momentum scores, risk-off signals and defensive switches, and why period, rebalancing and costs change backtest results.
Read a dynamic asset allocation rule in three parts.
The first part is the momentum score: returns over several lookback periods are combined or compared to turn an asset’s recent trend into a number. The second is the risk-off signal. Some strategies, such as DAA and HAA, watch a separate set of “canary” assets; others, such as VAA, look at the scores of the offensive assets themselves, and LAA looks at unemployment and the equity trend. The third is the switching rule that moves the portfolio into cash-like assets or bonds when the signal turns negative.
VAA scores each asset by weighting its 1-, 3-, 6- and 12-month returns differently, and sets the share of defensive assets according to how many offensive assets score zero or below. In VAA-G4, a single offensive asset at or below zero is enough to move the whole portfolio into defensive assets. GEM moves into aggregate bonds when the 12-month return of US equities is not higher than that of Treasury bills; otherwise it holds whichever of US equities and developed-market equities has the higher 12-month return. LAA keeps a fixed allocation and changes only part of it based on unemployment and the equity trend.
Period, rebalancing and costs change the results.
The same strategy can produce very different results depending on where the test starts and ends, so look at several sub-periods rather than a single window. The timing of rebalancing matters too — for example, whether the signal is calculated at month-end and trades are placed on the next trading day, or trades are placed at the start of the month. Check as well whether commissions, taxes and currency conversion are included.
On a strategy library page, read the rules and conditions first.
Each strategy page in the Quantus strategy library shows the trading rules, the rebalancing basis and the backtest results, and strategies that have a source cite it — a paper, book or article. Read the rules and conditions before the performance figures: understand which assets the strategy uses and what makes its signal change, and only then look at the results. When comparing strategies, check that their periods and cost assumptions match.
CAVEAT
Limits to keep in mind
- A backtest is a simulation based on historical data and does not guarantee future returns.
- This article is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any asset.
EVIDENCE
Sources and further reading
PRODUCTS
See it in the product
STRATEGIES